Yusuf Estes Dangerous Quran Mistake

User Rating: 3 / 5

Star ActiveStar ActiveStar ActiveStar InactiveStar Inactive

Rate now03
Is It Qur'An
= Recitation
Quran allahsquran1

Is it A Kitab = Book (?)

In the Name of Allah, the Most Compassionate, the Most Merciful
Concept of Kitab in the Quran
Yusuf Estes and the Understandings From Dr. Bilal Philips


On this website (Islam Newsroom) we had a Big Mistake - (out of 2,500 pages this was bound to happen)

By the way, we thank our brothers and sisters who pointed out the error in an article posted at the end of Ramadan (Aug 24-25, 2012). It was removed it as soon as discovered, and replaced with this article.

But for sure it should not have happened, it was a dangerous big mistake and certainly not a teaching we hold and we pray it never happens again.

Also, we have hold no bad feelings toward any of our sisters and brothers who sincerely help us to do better in our effort to project the correct message of Islam in simple English terms. We truly say, without any hard feelings at all, "BIG THANK YOU & WE love you all for the sake of Allah".

Let us please keep in mind, as scholars and teachers of the past have said,
"If you find anything in our teaching which does not comply with the Quran and the Sunnah of our prophet, peace be upon him, then take what you find from the Quran and the sunnah and throw away whatever you have found from us"

All of the 4 great imams said similar to this. And we are certainly not even on the same level as they are. Thanks again to those who are helping us monitor our many webpages. May Allah reward you all, ameen.

PLEASE NOTE: Most of our articles and videos are directed to non-Muslims who have been attacking the Islam, Quran, Allah and our prophet, peace be upon him. Their misunderstanding of Quran is based on comparisions of what they know about the Bible and its problems, and from some deviants who have tried to confuse peope as to what the Quran really is all about - IN ENGLISH.

What do most people think about the words:

Does the Word QURAN mean 'Book'? *(kitab - in Arabic) - answer: Yes. Both are correct.

Does the Word KITAB mean 'Read'? (Iqra' - in Arabic) answer:
No. "Iqra'a" (from same root as Quran) has the meaning of the imperative of the verb "qa ra 'a" (recite) and with the Arabic letter "Alief" in front of it is the direct order to "recite" - NOT read.

quran 2

(Divine Book)

The Revelations of the Quran
Dr. Abu Ameenah Bilal Philips

According to Allah's statements in His Book, there were two distinct revelations of the Quran which took place. It is important that these two revelations be understood in order to clear up the apparent contradictions in the various terms used in the Quran and Sunnah to describe the Quran's revelation. On one hand, the Quran is referred to as having been revealed in its totality in Ramadan or on Laylatul-Qadr, the Night of Decree; while on the other hand, it is referred to as having been continuously revealed in segments up until just before the death of the Prophet (peace be upon him).

The First Revelation

Allah caused the Quran to descend from the Protected Tablet (al-Lawh al-Mahfuth) on which it was written to the lowest heaven. In this revelation all of the Quran was sent down at one time to a station in the lowest heaven referred to as "Bayt al-'Izzah" (The House of Honor or Power). The blessed night on which this descent took place is called "Laylatul-Qadr" (The Night of Decree), one of the odd-numbered nights in the last ten days of the month of Ramadan. Allah referred to this initial revelation as follows:

"Haa Meem. By the Clear Book, verily, I revealed it in a blessed night." [Noble Quran 44:1-3]
"Verily, I revealed it on the Night of Decree." [Noble Quran 97:1]
"The month of Ramadan in which I revealed the Quran as guidance to mankind" [Noble Quran 2:185]
These verses have to refer to the initial revelation because it is a known fact that the whole Quran was not revealed to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) on a single night in Ramadan. Ibn 'Abbas stated that the Quran was first separated from its station in the upper heavens and placed in Bayt al-'Izzah in the lowest heaven. One version states that this took place on the Night of Decree in Ramadan. Had it been Allah's wish, the Quran could then have been revealed as a whole to the Prophet (peace be upon him) in a single revelation.
This was the method by which all of the earlier books of revelation were sent down. But, Allah chose to divide the revelation into two parts. The first revelation within the heavens represented an announcement to the inhabitants of the heavens that the final book of revelation was being sent down upon the last of the prophets.

From the lowest heaven sections of the Quran were then taken down by the angel Jibril to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). This process of revelation continued over the twenty-three years of his prophethood. This revelation began with the first five verses of Surah al-'Alaq. These verses were revealed to the Prophet (peace be upon him) while he was on a spiritual retreat in the cave of Hira' near Makkah. However, the first complete Surah to be revealed was Surah al-Fatihah. The revelation of this portion of Quran marked the beginning of the final phase of prophethood. The last Surah to be revealed was Surah an-Nasr. This Surah was brought down in Mina during the Farewell Hajj of the Prophet (peace be upon him), which took place at the end of the tenth year after the Hijrah. According to Ibn 'Abbas, the last verse to be revealed was verse 281 in Surah al-Baqarah, the last of a series of verses dealing with interest. Allah has referred to the second revelation in the following way:

"And (it is) a Quran which I have divided into parts in order that you (Muhammad) may recite it to the people gradually, and I have revealed it by successive revelation."
[Noble Quran 17:106]

Quran: Definition of the Term
The word "Quran," a verbal noun, is equivalent in meaning to "qira'ah," as both come from the verb "qara'a" which means "to read."
That is, Quran literally means "a reading or reciting." However, the term "Quran" has been historically used specifically to refer to the book which was revealed to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). The term "Quran" is mentioned in a number of places throughout the book in reference to itself.
For example:
"Verily, this Quran guides (humanity) to that which is most just. [Noble Quran 17:9]
The name Quran is used to refer to both the Quran as a whole, as in the previously quoted verse; as well as to each verse or group of verses, as in the following verse:

"And if the Quran is recited, you should listen to it and be silent, that you may receive mercy." [Noble Quran 7:204]

The Book has also been referred to by other names; for example, the Furqan (The Distinction):

"Blessed is He who revealed the Furqan to His slave in order that he may be a warner to all the worlds." [Noble Quran 25:1]
And of course, the Dhikr, (The Reminder):
"Verily, I revealed the Dhikr and verily I will preserve it." [Noble Quran 15:9]

The Quran could be defined as Allah's words which were revealed in Arabic in a rhythmical form to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). Its recitation is used in acts of worship and its smallest chapter (Surah) is of a miraculous nature.

The Prophet's divinely inspired statements which were recorded by his followers are generally referred to as hadiths. For example, the Prophet's companion (sahabi), 'Umar ibn al-Khattab, reported that he once said, "Verily, deeds are (judged) by their intentions."

However, in some of his statements, the Prophet (peace be upon him) attributed what he said to Allah; for example, another sahabi, Abu Hurayrah, reported that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said, "Allah, Most High, says, 'I am as My slave thinks of Me and I am with him when he remembers me. So if he remembers Me to himself, I will remember him to Myself and if he remembers Me in a group, I will remember him in a better group.' "

In order to distinguish this type of hadith from the previous type, it is referred to as hadith qudsi (sacred hadith) and the former referred to as hadith An-Nabawi (prophetic hadith).

The Quran, however, is not the same as hadith qudsi for a number of reasons.

First, the Quran is from Allah both in its wording and in its meaning, while in the case of hadith qudsi, its meaning is from Allah but its wording was the Prophet's (peace be upon him).

Second, Allah challenged the Arabs and mankind in general to produce even a chapter equivalent to one of the Quran's chapters, and their inability to do so proves its miraculous nature. This is not so in the case of hadith qudsi.

Third, the recitation of the Quran is used in salah and is itself considered a form of worship. The Prophet (Peace be upon him) said,
"Whoever reads a letter from the book of Allah, the Most High, will get a good deed (recorded for him), and each good deed is worth ten times its value. I am not only saying that Alif Laam Meem is a letter, but I am also saying that Alif is a letter, Laam is a letter, and Meem is a letter."

However, the recitation of hadith qudsi does not carry these properties.

The Main Theme of the Quran

Not only is the Quran unique among books today in its origin and purity, but it is also unique in the way it presents its subject matter.

It is not a book in the usual sense of the word wherein there is an introduction, explanation of the subject, followed by a conclusion.

Neither is it restricted to only a presentation of historical events, problems of philosophy, facts of science or social laws, though all may be found woven together in it without any apparent connection and links.

Subjects are introduced without background information, historical events are not presented in chronological order, new topics sometimes crop up in the middle of another for no apparent reason, and the speaker and those spoken to change direction without the slightest forewarning.

The reader who is unaware of the Quran's uniqueness is often puzzled when he finds it contrary to his understanding of a book in general and a "religious" book in particular. Hence, the Quran may seem disorganized and haphazard to him.

However, to those who understand its subject matter, aim and its central theme, the Quran is exactly the opposite.

The subject matter of the Quran is essentially man: man in relation to his Lord and Creator, Allah; man in relation to himself; and man in relation to the rest of creation. The aim and object of the revelations is to invite man to the right way of dealing with his Lord, with himself, and with creation. Hence, the main theme that runs throughout the Quran is that God alone deserves worship and, thus, man should submit to God's laws in his personal life and in his relationships with creation in general. Or, in other words, the main theme is a call to the belief in Allah and the doing of righteous deeds as defined by Allah.

Now, if you, the reader keep these basic facts in mind, you will likely find that, from beginning to end, the Quran's topics are all closely connected to its main theme and that the whole book is a well-reasoned and cohesive argument for its theme.

The Quran keeps the same object in view, whether it is describing the creation of man and the universe or events from human history. Since the aim of the Quran is to guide man, it states or discusses things only to the extent relevant to this aim and leaves out unnecessary and irrelevant details. It also repeats its main theme over and over again in the presentation of each new topic.

Significance of the Quran's Preservation

Allah promised in the Quran that He would take on the responsibility of protecting His final word from loss. He said, "Verily I have revealed the Reminder (Quran), and verily I shall preserve it." (Surah al-Hijr (15):9)

Thus, the Quran has been preserved in both the oral as well as written form in a way no other religious book in history has.

Why did Allah preserve the Quran and allow His earlier books of divine revelation to be changed or lost?

The answer to that question lies in the following three facts:

The earlier prophets and their books were sent to a particular people in particular periods of history. Once the period ended, a new prophet was sent with a new book to replace the previous book. So, it was not necessary that these books be preserved by Allah.

The preservation of the earlier books was left up to the people as a test for them. Thus, when the people went astray, they changed what was written in the books which their prophets brought in order to make allowable the things which were forbidden to them. In that way, all of the earlier books of revelation became either changed or lost.

Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was the last prophet whom Allah sent, and he was not sent to a particular people or a particular time. He was sent to all of mankind until the end of the world. Allah said in the Quran:

"I have only sent you (Muhammad) as a giver of glad tidings and a warner to all mankind, but most men do not understand." [Noble Quran 34:28]

Therefore, his book of revelation, the Quran, had to be specially preserved from any form of change or loss so that it would be available to all the generations of man until the last day of the world.
The Quran was the main miracle given to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) to prove that he was a true prophet of Allah and not an imposter. So, the Quran had to be saved to prove to the later generations that Muhammad (peace be upon him) was really the last prophet of Allah.
All of the false prophets who came after Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) brought books which they claimed to be revealed from Allah, but none of them have the miraculous ability to be memorized by thousands, nor have they improved on the message of the Quran.
The significance of the Quran's preservation is that Islam has been kept in its original purity because of it. Humanity can always return to the sources of Islam no matter what people may have added or forgotten in time. All of the essential principles of Islam are to be found in the Quran. Consequently, the preservation of the Quran meant the preservation of Islam in its final form.
The loss of the Gospel of Jesus means that Christians can never return to the true teachings of Prophet Jesus except by accepting Islam. Similarly, the original Torah was lost when Solomon's Temple in Jerusalem was destroyed by the Babylonians.
Thus, the Jews cannot return to the pure teachings of Prophet Moses except by following Islam. It is only in Islam that the pure teachings of the prophets have been preserved without any change.
That is why Allah said in the Quran: "Verily, the only acceptable religion to Allah is Islam." [Noble Quran 3:19]

Some of the Magnificent Characteristics of the Quran

Allah has described the Noble Quran with a number of magnificent characteristics of which Ibn Qudamah mentioned eight in points 27 - 30 of Lum'atul-I'tiqad.

They are as follows:

That it is clear (mubin) and makes clear the laws and reports which it contains.

That it is Allah's firm rope (Hablullah), that is, it is the solid contract which Allah made a reason for reaching Himself and the attainment of success by His Grace.

That it consists of distinct chapters (muhkamat), each distinct from the other, perfected and preserved from any flaws or contradictions.

That it consists of clear verses (ayat bayyinat) which are clear and obvious signs indicating Allah's unique unity, the perfection of His attributes, and the goodness of His laws.

That it contains clear and obscure verses (ayat muhkamat wa mutashabihat); the clear being that whose meaning is clear and the obscure being those whose meaning is hidden.

And this does not contradict point number three above because the clarity there refers to perfection and protection from flaws and contradiction, while here it refers to clarity of meaning. If the obscure is referred back to the clear, all of it will become clear.

That it is the truth (haqq) that cannot be affected by falsehood from any direction.

That it is free from its description by the disbelievers as being poetry, magic or human speech.

That it is a miracle that no one can imitate even with the help of others.

Question: Does the word 'kitab' when used in the Quran ever refer to itself (as being the Quran)?

Answer: Yes.

Another meaning of the word Kitab is the Quran itself.
As it is known, the Quran is a Recitation in Divine revelation, in the form of a scripture (from the Book with Allah - "Kitab Allah").

Quran calls itself Quran, because it is recited.

And Quran calls itself Kitab, because it is written or scripted, in the Book with Allah.

So, both Quran and Kitab are used for this Revelation.

Question: Where is the Quran of Allah?  [CLICK for answer in this article]

The following verses signify these names: "God it is Who has sent down the Book with the Truth, and also the Balance." (42: 17)

"By the Clear Book, behold,We have made it an Arabic Qur'an; haply you will understand.." (43:12)

“That is the Book, wherein is no doubt.." (2: 2)


More? Check this out . .

Video: Quran is NOT just a Book (yusuf estes)

Also: Yusuf Estes Exposes "Bakkah . ." for what it really is . .
Read . .

1 COMMENTS_bottom_page
One click only please


#8 Bro in Mauritius 2014-02-08 16:27
salams to all
Yusuf Estes came to Mauritius for LIVE ISLAM conference with Hussein Yee, Abduraheem Green, Mehdi Kabir and others.
i just read comments here and love what these guys are doing for humanity.
They covered three important topics - Knowledge, Faith & Unity.
This was a very great chance for all of them to come together and share with us.
May Allah Bless these speakers, ameen. And may Allah give us more conferences like this here in Mauritius, amen.
#7 Madeeha Bokhari 2013-01-14 08:29
Assalamu 'alaikum__I am a student of Dr. Bilal Philips at IOU and I have been listening to Sheikh Yusuf Estes' talks (youtube videos, programs on Peace TV) for quite a few years now. When this problem about the Qur'an not being a book came up and it was causing fitnah (people writing against you etc), I prayed for you Sheikh Yusuf Estes. Alhamdulillah this has been clarified. Alhamdulillah._ _May Allaah reward you with the best of both the worlds, keep you steadfast upon the deen. Allaahu Akbar!__Wassala mu 'alaikum
#6 Yusuf Estes 2013-01-06 05:48
Salam alaykum,
Regarding mistakes about Quran, all of us need to help each other with wisdom and good teaching.
This is a blessing from our religion of Islam.
I hope we always encourage and remind each other to be steadfast and patient while we learn & share.
All comments are welcome and we will publish all AFTER REVIEW of course.
Thanks again and Allah Bless to all who are sincerely helping us.
#5 sister 2012-09-20 17:23
We pray toALLAH for the success of this site and help it grow Ameen
#4 I.A. 2012-09-01 06:31
Obviously, someone doesn't know Yusuf Estes owns www.Qtafsir.com one of the most beautiful websites in English for the Quran tafsir by Ibn Kathir.
It is clear beyond doubt to me, Dr. Bilal Philips and Yusuf Estes present some of the best understandings for people like me.
Jazahum Allahu Khairan - peace to all.
#3 Mubeen 2012-08-30 19:54
Jazak Allah Shaikh Yusuf and Shaikh Billal. It realy helped me in better understanding of Quran as miracle.May Allah help me and all to put this in practice. Ameen
#2 Muslim Brother 2012-08-28 17:35
Assalamu-alaiku m.
It may have been that the title of the previous article which our brothers made a mistake in was called "Qur'an is NOT a kitab". This article is a correction of that previous one as He pointed out. Qur'an can be called a kitab.
I'm not one hundred percent sure of what I wrote. I may be wrong! Hopefully not though.

EDITOR: From what I understand, the original article had a question mark ? at the end, as it does now and was to stimulate interest like many of our articles do. However, there was a portion inserted by mistake from a source not acceptable to us and it has since been corrected and actually replaced with another article from Yusuf Estes website www.AllahsQuran.com from Dr. Bilal Philips.
#1 Seibars 2012-08-21 09:17
The title says Quran is NOT kitaab! and the conclusion is "So, both Quran and Kitab are used for this book." Please help me I'm confused. Also, is the writing in mushaf-e-sherif considered Quran or not? THanks and peace on sheik Yusuf Estes and all the people at the Islamic News Room! EDITOR: there is a question mark at the end. It was not saying so, it was asking the question.

Need permission to post comment