Muslims at Thanksgiving?

User Rating: 5 / 5

Star ActiveStar ActiveStar ActiveStar ActiveStar Active

What About Thanksgiving?
Thanksgiving Day

Celebrate 4th of July? Christmas?



Answer: Al Hamdulillah, was salat was salam ala rasoolullah. Allahu 'Alim.

1. The day of 'Thanks' in the U.S. is usually thought of as a day of being grateful and to give thanks to Almighty God for all we have.
It is in this context most Muslims feel confortable in sharing this day of thanks with all their non-Muslim family and friends and even consider it as a chance for 'dawah' (inviting to Islam).

2. However, there are others who consider this inappropriate as it does have some religious over tones and it should be avoided to be on the safe side.

3. Still others think of a way to do both at the same time. That is, to avoid eating anything at all, but still be with the non-Muslims and be ready to give some important information about Islam and Muslims.

How?  -- By fasting on the day of Thanksgiving.

As you know, fasting on the days of Monday and Thursday were a custom of our prophet, peace be upon him, and he encouraged us to follow this excellent habit, not only for good health reasons, but to draw closer to Allah by forsaking the pleasures of this world.

What an excellent chance to avoid eating anything that might not be halal (kosher) but yet, still be with your friends and family and even offer a quick lesson in some of the teachings of our wonderful way of life called - Islam (Submission to the Will of God, in peace).

Regardless of which of the opinions you choose to follow, do keep in mind - Muslims can never compromise their beliefs or acts of worship to join along with others for the sake of just 'getting along' or thinking it will make people like Islam.

Also, keep in mind it is not proper to put down other Muslms who have chosen a different opinion to follow, provided of course it comes from reliable teachers who base their answers on Quran and sunnah.

Answer provided by Yusuf Estes, former U.S. National Muslim Chaplain


What are the real meanings of these "Holy Days"?

Like April Fool's Day? St. Patrick's Day? 4th of July?

Some days are truly "Holy Days" (the word "holiday" means a "holy day") while other days celebrated might be patriotic or commemerative days.

An examples of "holidays" would be any associated with any religion's form of worship, such as:
Christmas; Easter; Yaum Kipur; St. Patrick's Day; Halloween; New Year's and Valentine's Day

Commemorative days are:
Labor Day; Thanksgiving Day; Mother's Day; Father's Day

Patriotic Days are:
Memorial Day; July 4th; Washington's Birthday; Lincoln's Birthday

NOTE: Muslims were told by prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, they have two (2) occassions for celebration:
Eid Al Fitar and Eid Al Adha (end of Ramadan and end of hajj).

Halloween has evolved and been influenced by a number of different cultures and religions, the most important of which are paganism, the Romans, the Celts (the people of Ireland, Scotland, Britain, Wales) and Christianity.

However, almost all of the traditions surrounding Halloween as we know it today can be traced back to the Celtic Day of the Dead, a pagan holiday.

Samhain was the name of the Druid god of the dead. The Druids were a religious order amongst the Celts. On this day, they would try to appease their Lord of Death. These Druids also believed that witches rode on broom sticks and that ghosts were the cause of supernatural occurrences.

The belief was that on the eve of the Celtic New Year (which for them was October 31), the souls of the dead people roamed the land of the living. The Devil, spirits and witches were also believed to be moving about and at the height of their power.

Halloween was also a time for MAJOR Shirk (making partners with Allah).

There were games and rituals which involved fortune-telling Young people, for instance, would try to see what their marriage prospects were using omens like apple pairings that were thrown over their shoulders, or nuts being burned in a fire.

The Pope, in the eight century, decided to Christianize this pagan holiday since he wanted people to abandon the occult and idolatrous practices associated with it, and made November 1st All Saints' Day or All Hallows' (Holy) Day. This is a day to remember all of the Christians who died for their faith. October 31 was then considered All Hallow's Eve, and this word later evolved into the modern day Halloween.

Some reasons behind certain Halloween traditions:

Most of the Halloween activities participated in today can be traced back to occult symbolism. For example:

1. Dressing up in costumes: This was done so that the spirits of the dead would not recognize people. The Druids would actually sacrifice animals and sometimes humans and dress in these animal skins. Wearing these clothes, the would engage in fortune-telling

Another explanation is that today, children who dress up represent these spirits

2. Trick-or-treating: The Druids would go from house to house on October 31 and demand specific types of food. If their demands were not met, it was believed the people and their homes would be cursed with trouble, sickness and death. Prosperity was promised to those who generously donated.

Today, when kids are offered treats by neighbors, this goes back to the time people would offer food to appease the spirits.

3. Jack-o'-lantern: This started off as a legend associated with a man of Irish origin named Jack who supposedly enjoyed playing pranks on the Devil. After his death, Jack did not go to Heaven or Hell and therefore, had to wander the earth carrying a lantern which gave him some light to see where he was going. Pumpkins that were hollowed out and had candles lighted inside did the job and they were also supposed to scare evil spirits away.

Some consider them as symbols of torches of Halloweens past.

Advice to Muslims for Halloween:

1. Avoid it, it's a night of evil. Shaytan (Satan) is our open enemy and we do not play with evil.

2. Trick-or-treating is really kids begging for candy. Prophet Mohammed (peace and blessings be upon him) disliked and discouraged begging.

3. Remember that Satanic movements have engaged in dangerous acts, like rape and kidnapping on Halloween.

Dealing with Halloween: 13 tips for parents

So your kids have come home and begged you to go trick-or-treating on Halloween night (October 31). They can't wait for all of the bubble gum, lollipops and jawbreakers, not to mention dressing up in a Pokemon or witch costume like the rest of their friends.

You watch all of this in dismay. Knowing that Halloween is about Shirk (making partners with Allah) and Shaytan (see video review of Holiday Myths) you want to put your foot down once and for all and not let the kids go out that evening.

These are their tips about how you can deal with the Halloween hoopla:

Tip #1: Find out exactly what Halloween is

Too often, parents themselves are in the dark about the background of occasions and holidays like Halloween. Don't think this is a trivial matter.

Once you find out why Halloween is celebrated, you will think twice about getting your kids involved.

In fact, any parent who is trying to raise his or her child as a God-conscious individual will object to the celebration of the occasion. Just spend an hour at the library looking it up in the encyclopedia. To get an Islamic perspective, check out a review of Holiday Myths.

If you discuss it with your kids using correct information, and they sense that you know what you are talking about, they may even agree with you about not participating in the ritual.

Tip #2: Talk to them at least a few weeks in advance

This is made easier by the fact that Halloween sales of candy and costumes are already underway and the yearly ritual of horror movies being released or shown on television (see our unTV guide) will soon begin.

So the atmosphere is right to sit Aisha or Ali down to have a talk about Halloween. Talking to them now as opposed to on the morning of October 31 will give them some time to think about it too, and get used to the concept of not having to go trick-or-treating just because their friends are.

Tip #3: Rationally explain that we have our own celebrations

Talking about Halloween in the context of a fiery speech about how "these non-Muslims are so evil" will not help Aisha or Ali see why they should not participate.

Your histrionics will only blind them to reality. Instead, explain that every group or culture has its own celebrations, and we, as Muslims have our own. Halloween is a pagan celebration. But when Eid comes, that is our celebration.

Do not condemn those who celebrate Halloween. Rather, explain what it is calmly, point out its dangers, and let your kids think about it.

Tip #4: Mention the other dangers of Halloween

Horror stories about razor blades in apples, Ex-Lax laxative given instead of chocolate to trick-or-treaters, or the dangers on the street should also be mentioned, but not made the focus of the reasons why you object to Halloween.

Tip #5: Explain that every one of our occasions has a meaning

Remind your kids that for Muslims, our holidays always have a good, positive meaning.

For example, at Eid-ul-Fitr, we celebrate our joy of fasting during the blessed month of Ramadan, which is a time we strive to get closer to Allah and be better Muslims.

Halloween, on the other hand, is celebrated partly as a reminder of Shaytan, who is evil, and from whom everyone should avoid and seek refuge in Allah from.

Tip #6: Emphasize that there is nothing wrong with being different

This is crucial because there will be other occasions later on in their lives when Muslim children must not participate in school activities (for example, the Prom.

This does not mean permanent exclusion from all school and/or peer activities, but it means that as Muslims, they can take what is good, but they also have to learn to reject what is bad in a wise manner.

Tip #7: Meet your child's teacher to discuss it

Arrange a meeting to discuss Halloween and celebrations or activities you, as a Muslim would not want your child to be involved in. But also talk about what kinds of activities you would recommend or approve of, and discuss Muslim celebrations.

Volunteer to come in during Ramadan, for example, to present and bring food for the kids during a talk about what is the month's significance for Muslims. For more tips see 17 Tips for Parents to Present Ramadan in your Child's Class

Tip #8: Don't send them to school the day of Halloween if there's a party

If the teacher has scheduled a class Halloween party, simply don't send Ali or Aisha to school that day.

However, before you do this, you should write a short letter or note to the teacher and/or principal explaining why your son or daughter will not be attending school that day.

Tip # 9: Take them to a Muslim friend's house on Halloween

Don't make this a special occasion. If you regularly meet with other Muslim families and your children are friends with their children, visit them or invite them over just to play or hang out. This can take their minds off the Halloween hysteria happening outside.

Tip #10: Take them out for a doughnut

Or anything else Halal, just so you are not home when trick-or-treaters come knocking, which will reinforce the Halloween hysteria.

Tip #11: Turn off the lights, close the windows and educate your neighbors

Turning off the lights will give the message this home isn't really interested in Halloween. Closing the windows may be necessary, since throwing eggs at someone's home who hasn't given candy is not uncommon on Halloween.

Educate your neighbors about Halloween by posting a brief polite note about why you are not celebrating the occasion. Shaema Imam for example, on one Halloween, posted a decorative note on her door telling neighbors she does not support the pseudo-satanic glorification of evil as represented by Halloween. However, she said it is excellent that there is neighborhood cooperation to promote children's safety on Halloween (there were efforts in her area to ensure kids could trick-or-treat in safety).

She also expressed her support for the collection of money for Unicef, which children sometimes do when they go trick-or-treating. Imam didn't get any comments, but no one egged her house either, she says.

Tip #12: Spread the word: two to three weeks in advance, organize a seminar

This would be for Muslim moms, dads and their young kids. There should be a presentation on what exactly Halloween is and what Muslim parents can do about it.

While this is being discussed, kids should be allowed to play together under the supervision of a couple of baby-sitters. This will serve to inform moms and dads, while giving kids a chance to have fun (and perhaps set up an invitation so they can avoid Halloween night craziness-see Tip #9)

Tip #13: Keep your promise about Eid

For a number of Muslim youth who have grown up in North America, Eid is sometimes just another day, with parents not even taking a day off work.

In other cases, while parents may take the day off, the ritual is the same: get up, put on new clothes, drive to fancy hall, pray, not understand what's really going on, hug Eid Mubarak, go back home, eat "ethnic" food, get money (as Eid gift). Period. It's no wonder our kids' eyes light up when they see Christmas lights, brightly wrapped gifts and hear of Halloween fun and treats.

Make Eid special. Don't just hype it up during Halloween to convince the kids not to participate and then break your promise.

On Eid, give the kids candy, take them out to dinner or an amusement park. Organize a party and invite their friends over. Arrange for them to have a gift exchange. The possibilities for Halal fun are there. We owe it to our kids, if we want them to stay Muslim and to be proud of it, to celebrate the occasions in life that really matter to us, like the two Eids.


"A person who calls another to guidance will be rewarded, as will the one who accepts the message." (Tirmithi)


Please forward this message to your friends.




#5 Heike 2015-11-27 01:39
I do not participate in any Western holiday, it is not easy with all Western family here but then again , it is not always an easy road to follow Allah but well worth it in the end. We are not meant to indulge in this earthly life.
#4 canada 2010-09-30 09:04
zazak Allah usuf estes for this information. my 7 yrs daughter watches ur show on peace tv.she likes u sooo much.yes we do not take part in it.whenever any issue comes that is not islamic i ask her do u love Allah and prophet most or this?? Alhumdulillah she always said Allah and our prophet(s.a).th at was the end.we have to teach our children whom we should love most rather than anything/anyone even their own. this formula works for me and also for my children.when we love anyone most,then we listen to him most. assalamu alaikum .
#3 iffat 2010-07-12 01:57
We moved to canada about 2years back and Halloween was a new concept for us but Alhumdulilah we didnot take part in it and we have decided not to send our kids to school on the days of halloween and infact kids came to our door asking for candy and Alhumdulilah i just told them one clear thing
#2 Fahad Bajawi 2010-06-23 09:25
Bismellah Arahman Araheem
Thanks for subject
infact in islam and muslims we here have three occasions when celebrate Eid al jumaah, Eid al fiter after fasting Ramadan, Eid AL hajj and alhamdullelah for this and thanks for you dear sh yusuf
#1 anonymous 2010-06-14 22:01
Assalamu alaykum,_May Allah reward you abundantly for this post and may Allah accept it as havin been done for His sake only!!_Would u tell, how would u respond to someone who wishes u on the first day of Rajab or any other month of (I aint quite sure) Islamic Lunar Calendar [?] and claims that RasulAllah said if u wish on the first day of the month then you're guaranteed Jannat? And, if u ask that person to provide the evidence and he replies : it's about my belief._Please, explain, it's about lyin against the Prophet and I wish it were only about such people's belief!!_Jazaka llahu Khair_Wassalamu Alaikum

Need permission to post comment